July 2009 numbers are listed below for 20 metropolitan areas

Minneapolis, up 4.6%; San Francisco, up 3.3%; Chicago, up 2.7%; San Diego, Calif., up 2.5%; Atlanta, up 2.3%; Los Angeles, up 1.8%; Phoenix, up 1.8%; Washington, up 1.8%; Cleveland, up 1.5%; Denver, up 1.5%; Tampa, Fla., up 1.4%; Miami, up 1.3%; Boston, up 1.2%; Dallas, up 1.2%; Detroit, up 1.1%; Portland, Ore., up 1.1%; New York, up 0.8%; Charlotte, N.C., up 0.6%; Seattle, down 0.1%; and Las Vegas, down 1.1%.

NY was up .8%

Year over year numbers are listed below

Las Vegas, down 31.4%; Phoenix, down 28.5%; Detroit, down 24.6%; Miami, down 21.2%; Tampa, Fla., down 18.4%; San Francisco, down 17.9%; Minneapolis, down 17.3%; Seattle, down 15.3%; Los Angeles, down 14.9%; Chicago, down 14.2%; Portland, Ore., down 13.9%; San Diego, Calif., down 12.3%; Atlanta, down 11.8%; New York, down 10.3%; Washington, down 9.8%; Charlotte, N.C., down 9%; Boston, down 4.9%; Denver, down 2.9%; Dallas, down 1.6%; and Cleveland, down 1.3%.

NY is down  10.3%

Year over year